House panel OKs crackdown on illegal immigrants
On party-line votes in a packed hearing room, a House subcommittee last week endorsed a legislative package that Republicans said will curb illegal immigration but opponents said may unfairly punish undocumented residents and promote discrimination.
The immigration subcommittee of the House Courts of Justice Committee approved bills to make Virginia’s public colleges and universities spell out their policies against enrolling illegal immigrants; have the Virginia State Police enforce federal immigration laws; require public contractors to verify that their employees are legal U.S. residents; and check the immigration status of everyone arrested in Virginia.
Most of the bills were endorsed on 4-2 votes, with Republicans voting yes and Democrats no.
Nearly every seat in the 204-person-capacity room was taken, and a Capitol Police officer stood watchfully over the proceedings, as the subcommittee considered 17 immigration-related bills Friday. Thirteen of the proposals were approved (or were folded into related bills and then approved); they now will be considered by the full House Courts of Justice Committee.
Delegate Jackson Miller, R-Manassas, reflected the tenor of the Republican majority on the subcommittee in arguing for the employment verification requirement.
“The issue is being framed as one of meanness,” Miller said. “It’s not. If you’re here illegally, I want you to leave. I welcome you back legally with open arms.”
About half the audience applauded; they were called out of order by the subcommittee chairman, Delegate Todd Gilbert, R-Woodstock.
The legislation’s opponents were equally impassioned. Danny Navarro of the Latino Student Alliance at the University of Virginia, for example, testified against the proposal to prohibit illegal immigrants from enrolling in state colleges and universities.
“This bill is an attempt to stunt the academic growth of undocumented citizens,” Navarro said.
House Bill 1465, sponsored by Delegate Christopher Peace, R-Mechanicsville, would require public colleges and universities to have written rules against enrolling “an alien who is unlawfully present in the United States.” Peace said most state schools already have such a policy: “They don’t have to do anything but put it in writing.”
The subcommittee folded into Peace’s measure HB 2153, sponsored by Delegate Ben Cline, R-Amherst. Cline’s proposal would make illegal immigrants ineligible for in-state tuition.
A long line of groups testified against the legislation. They ranged from Jews United for Justice to the Virginia Catholic Conference.
“We have earned the right to compete for admission,” Navarro said. “The immigration laws fail to address the ‘dreamers’” – the children of illegal immigrants who were brought here as young children and have grown up believing themselves to be Americans.
Juan Milanés of the Hispanic Bar Association agreed.
“These kids are dreamers because, more than anything, they want to be like you and me,” Milanés said. “These kids are trying to be here as productive members of society. They are not asking for an extra leg up.”
Gilbert responded, “The issue is finite resources. There are not enough slots in our public colleges and universities for our kids right now.”
“Who’s ‘our kids’?” Milanés shot back.
Peace said undocumented aliens could still pay out-of-state tuition: “To say that this bill cuts off educational opportunity is hyperbole.”
After the discussion, the subcommittee voted 4-2 in favor of HB 1465. Republican Delegates Gilbert, David Albo of Springfield, Jackson Miller of Manassas and William Cleaveland of Roanoke voted yes; Democratic Delegates Vivian Watts of Annandale and Patrick Hope of Arlington voted no.
Enforcing Federal Laws
This bill, sponsored by Miller, would authorize the Virginia State Police to enter into an agreement with the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement service. Under the arrangement (known as a “287g” agreement), the State Police would enforce federal immigration laws. Albo had filed HB 1420, which was the same as Miller’s bill; it was rolled into HB 1934.
Many people in the room wore buttons depicting “287g” in a red circle with a slash through it.
Luis Ayola, a Puerto Rican student at the University of Virginia, described being stopped and questioned by “cops who were incredulous that I had ID. I haven’t been detained yet, but I’m not waiting until that happens. I’m against 287g.”
“How long were you inconvenienced?” Hope asked Ayola.
“The first time, an hour,” Ayola answered. “The second time, 20 minutes.”
Beatriz Amberman of the Hispanic Community Dialogue Organization in Hampton Roads said that “turning State Police into ICE officials” will be expensive and undermine public safety.
“Increased enforcement will cost millions that the federal government will not reimburse. Can you assure us that local government won’t be burdened with the costs of this?” Amberman asked.
Ben Greenberg of Virginia Organizing, a nonprofit group that works with low-income communities, called the bill “an invitation to racial profiling.”
Michael McLaughlin of the American Council for Immigration Reform said there have been no confirmed instances of racial profiling under the 287g program. He called the legislation a “cost effective” way to deal with the “immigration problem.”
The subcommittee approved HB 1934 by the same 4-2 vote.
Two bills would require public contractors to use E-Verify to determine whether their employees are eligible to work in the U.S. E-Verify is a free, internet-based service operated by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. It can match an employee’s name against Social Security and other government records. HB 1859, sponsored by Delegate Richard Anderson, R-Woodbridge, would apply to contractors who work for state agencies. HB 1727, by Delegate Charles Carrico, R-Galax, would apply to local governments and to contractors for local governments. The subcommittee voted 4-2 for both bills after hearing testimony from all sides.
Construction industry representative Ryan Baker said such laws are needed.
“I see the effects of illegal immigration on a first-hand basis,” Baker said. He said contractors who hire illegal workers underbid other companies for government work. “If you don’t have to pay unemployment insurance or the wages that U.S. citizens get, you can do things a lot cheaper."
Representatives of the tea party movement and Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli also supported the E-Verify requirement.
Many groups opposed such a requirement, especially on local governments. They included the Coalition of Virginia Employers, the Virginia Chamber of Commerce, the Virginia Retail Merchants Association, the Virginia chapter of Associated Builders and Contractors, the Virginia Association of Counties and the Virginia Municipal League.
Opponents said the E-Verify program has a high error rate and puts more administrative responsibilities (with associated cost) on small employers.
HB 1430, sponsored by Albo, would ensure that police check the immigration status of everyone arrested in Virginia. A similar measure – HB 2332, by Delegate Scott Lingamfelter, R-Woodbridge, was rolled into HB 1430.
“My intent is that everybody who gets arrested gets checked,” Albo said. “Some sheriffs are only checking those who get bond or who are released on their own recognizance.”
Albo said the legislation would target just people being arrested: “We’re not seeking to do immigration checks on people on the street – only that everyone who gets taken before a magistrate gets checked.”
Many groups that opposed other legislation before the immigration subcommittee had no problem with HB 1430.
“It doesn’t go into effect unless there is probable cause for a warrant or a magistrate has seen the person,” Castañaga said. “It’s not a situation where a police officer picks someone up because ‘they don’t look right.’”
Still, some immigration advocates said they want to make sure that police don’t use the legislation as a pretext to ask people to prove they are legal residents.
The subcommittee voted 5-1 for HB 1430. Hope was the lone dissenter.
Among participants at the Seventh Annual Coordinators2Inc Golf Tournament and awards luncheon Oct. 3 were (from left) Rebecca Ricardo, C2 Inc executive director; Kevin Derr, member of the winning foursome; Sharon Richardson, C2 Inc founder; and Frank Ridgway and Jon King, members of the winning foursome.
Held at The Crossings Golf Club, the tournament will benefit placement of children from Virginia's foster care system into permanent families through Coordinators2. > Read more.
Event will help kick of Marine Corps' 'Toys for Tots' campaign
All 140 A.C. Moore locations will serve as drop-off centers this year for the Marine Toys for Tots Foundation, and all toys collected will stay in the local communities served by the stores in which they are donated.
On Saturday, Nov. 15, the Willow Lawn location will kick off the month-long program by hosting a "Make & Take" craft event for kids. Children ages six and older will be able to make a craft and take it home with them. Representatives from the Marines will be in-store to teach customers about the Toys for Tots program. A.C. Moore team members will be on site to help with the crafts. > Read more.
Citizen Staff Reports 11/12/2014
Commonwealth Catholic Charities is in desperate need of food donations for its community food pantry that serves the region’s low-income families, according to officials with the Henrico-based nonprofit.
After moving into its new location this past summer, the agency has dedicated a larger space for the pantry but the shelves are practically empty.
“As we head into the holidays and the weather turns colder, the need for food becomes even more critical, but unfortunately our cupboards are nearly bare,” said Jay Brown, the agency’s director for the division of housing services. “Donations of food will allow us help provide.” > Read more.
Find out how your favorite dining establishments fared during their most recent inspections by the Virginia Department of Health. > Read more.
The Cultural Arts Center unveils a new exhibit – "Sizing Up!" – Nov. 20-Jan. 18 in the Gumenick Family Gallery.
Artist Chuck Larivey has spent the past three years "sizing up" – creating large-scale oil paintings that are designed to engage their viewers in a monumental way by using size to captivate them and make them a part of the artistic experience.
The exhibit is appropriate for all ages and is free and open to the public at the center, located at 2880 Mountain Road in Glen Allen. > Read more.
Are you still looking for some unique holiday gifts? There are hundreds of great options your family and friends will love at the Holly Spree on Stuart Avenue, Vintage Holiday Show and New Bridge Academy’s annual Christmas Bazaar. Shopping can be stressful so some relaxing activities can be found in Henrico this weekend as well, including “Richmond’s Finest” at The Cultural Arts Center at Glen Allen, the “Nutcracker Sweet” at Moody Middle School and a jazz concert at the Henrico Theatre. For all our top picks this weekend, click here! > Read more.
- More News
Nov. 20, 2014Click here to read the print edition.
- More Entertainment
- More Obituaries
- More Community
- More Opinions
- More Sports
ClassifiedsMedical Alert for Seniors - 24/7 monitoring. FREE Equipment. FREE Shipping. Nationwide Service. $29.95/Month CALL Medical Guardian Today 888-709-2147
CalendarAmerican Legion Post 125, located at 1401 Hilliard Rd., will host a turkey dinner from 1 p.m. to 4 p.m. Cost is $8 for adults and $5 for children 12… Full text